Why Are You Asking Me This?
April 13th, 2007
When you’re thinking about purchasing a search keyword on Yahoo! Search, you would expect to need to supply the folks at Yahoo! all sorts of information:
- the search term
- some copy for the advertisement
- the page to link to
- billing information
- credit card information
But, would you expect to have to supply your time zone? After all, what difference does it make which time zone you’re located in? Do they use it for pricing? For tracking you in some way?
When we ask users questions they don’t expect, they often become suspicious. It’s like when a cashier at the local store asks for your home phone numberyou have to wonder what they are going to do with that information.
The designers at Yahoo! obviously don’t want you to get suspicious of their time zone request. They’ve done a nice job of explaining exactly why:

Not only do they tell us why they need the time zone informationfor timing campaigns and accurately reporting your activitybut they also warn us we won’t have a chance to edit it later, so we best get it right from the outset.
Are you explaining all your information requests to your users?



April 13th, 2007 at 10:04 am
Jared,
I agree witht he basic context, but at what point does it becomee over communication and people start ignoring it. I think the amount of text in the above example is too much, shouldn’t it be more scannable?
Also, In you opinion is it better to put this up front or keep it behind a link like – “why are we asking this” or something like that.
- Alok Jain